38 Comments
User's avatar
Barbara Charis's avatar

In 1980, one of the best built and healthiest fifty year old man I ever saw ...was simply into eating lots of fruit and raw vegetable salads. He would enter contests and beat out 20 - 30 year old men. He had all his hair, no gray, no glasses and a 28 inch waist. He had been on this diet, since he was 16 years old...and he worked out every other day. He did a lot of walking and surfing, too. The last time I spoke to him on the phone was several years ago, he was in his 90s and still biking around the town. He taught me to hold my hands over my food and ask the Creator to bless the food. He said that it doesn't have real value, until you ask a blessing. It 'energizes' it. At 92, I am healthier and more active than I was at 30. I followed his advice.

Fitness's avatar

Brought to you by Creapure. You have to be really careful about stuff that comes from the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition on this topic. It's got a long history on this, and a long history of misrepresenting information. The devil is very much in the detail:

"Because creatine increases intracellular water within muscle, some of the increase in lean mass may reflect increased cellular hydration rather than solely new muscle tissue."

It's almost certainly water. Lean mass doesn't automatically mean muscle. Lean mass is anything that's not fat.

For those interested we have a number of articles on this subject, including talking about the new interest in "10g" which appeared a few years back. Check out fitnesstroll on here.

Om's avatar

I agree. Exercise is key for metabolic health including weights. Why short circuit what is natural with potentially harmful effects? Thank you for posting your comments!!!

Dan Star's avatar

If it was just retained water, why would muscle strength increase?

Fitness's avatar

One has to start from the understanding that these scientists are joined at the hip with the company that makes Creapure, Alzchem Trostberg GmbH and have long history pushing creatine in a flawed way. That doesn't mean everything they say is wrong. But you have to start from that point. If they wanted the answer to that they could have specifically tested for it. Another thing is "untrained" in the study. Untrained it's possible to up strength without any significant muscle increase, it's more neural adaption at first. Creatine is assistive for strength work, yes, so could it in theory help in those untrained cases ? Is the water itself helping? Maybe. Assuming we're not looking at something else going on in the study. Does it create *dry* muscle out of thin air ? Probably not so much, esp in 12 weeks.

Lori's avatar

Great study! I don't know how you do it Nicolas getting all this research out to us so fast plus all else that your job requires. You are amazing!

Brandy's avatar

Taking isolated nutrients like creatine can potentially signal to your body to down regulate the enzymes needed for protein synthesis, thus leading to kidney disease in some people.

Sardines are high in whole food sourced creatine and other healthy nutrients.

Randy's avatar

Okay, I get why all the armchair experts in comment sections like to disparage stories about the effectiveness of supplements, natural food, or anything they don’t personally do or take every day. It’s human nature to bitch and complain.

In this very comment section I see that the publisher of the study is suspect because of its financial association with a manufacturer of the supplement under study and its “long history of misrepresentation” of medical information. If you read the study, which no one ever does before commenting, you would see the ACTUAL representation of the study results, which are not open to “misrepresentation.” You would also see that the disclosures report one researcher works for a supplement manufacturer, and the other 12 have no financial ties. But frankly, if a study is NOT paid for by a supplement manufacturer, who’s going to pay for it? There’s no money to be made from a supplement that costs pennies per dose unless you make the stuff. Of course, the same is true of Big Pharma manufacturers commissioning studies to prove their thousand-dollar drug works. What’s the alternative? Have the taxpayers pay for research studies? How much extra in taxes would YOU pay each year to prevent such conflicts of interest?

I also see a commenter saying that spending 12 weeks in a gym could DOUBLE the amount of lean mass gained by 12 weeks on the supplement. Okay, and…? Again, reading the study itself presents the following conclusions: “CrM supplementation with and without exercise and diet intervention may help middle-aged and older adults maintain muscle mass and strength while favourably affecting selected markers of health and cognitive function.” Note the words “middle-aged and older adults.” It’s not directed at young bucks, gym rats, and spandex bunnies. I’m 74 years old. I haven’t been to a gym in 30 years. Should I just sit at home and let my muscles waste away, or should I take a 5¢ scoop of powder each day to help mitigate the loss? Decisions, decisions… Take the advice of a “randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial” or the advice of armchair experts in a Substack comment section?

Elwood R. Bernat's avatar

Not fair boss man. The “bitcher’s and complainers” get a pass for a while longer since Covid as a right to be doubters, and ah, you sound like your age, “get off my lawn”.

The questions are valid, minus the doomers. Not to be to liberal minded like those that love their namesake liberty and “free” speech without paying for it, but you answered your own comment which apparently was your point to illuminate yourself.

Yeah, as we age the aches and pains tell us to get off our asses, get moving, drink water, sweat, and like combat veterans, do lots of electrolytes (salt tabs) but we tend to rather invert and project in our victimized status of late. Right where the marketeer’s want us to be so they can continue to be the Calvary that saves us. That’s it.

In fairness, your points about the research and responsibility are well taken, and unincorporated doctors (in short supply) have told us for ages to take the supplements if it make you feel better as long as they know about it.

Otherwise If you want to sit in the rocker and gulp five cent doses of creatine in your iced tea have at it for a while until it sits in the back of the cupboard and gets stale when most realize it did not achieve miraculous results yesterday.

Thanks for the opinion.

Randy's avatar

I gave you a "like," Elwood, even though I don't completely agree with your point of view, because I appreciate a robust difference of opinion.

Yes, COVID was a debacle. It killed the world's economy, killed our trust in mainstream medicine, and killed our trust in President Trump (it was HIS "Warp Speed" push to bring a new vaccine technology to market without the usual 5-year development cycle AND it was HIS brilliant idea to relieve the manufacturers of all liability for their drugs killing people). However, the COVID debacle should not be an excuse for throwing out ALL randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials -- especially trials of supplements that Big Pharma has no reason to fake because profit on these products is measured in pennies. Unfortunately, the pendulum has swung from blind trust in all medical professionals (e.g., my mother's generation) to blind DIStrust in all medical professionals (e.g. Substack's bitchers and complainers). A bit of nuance is needed.

As for me, I was a medical researcher for 28 years before I retired, so I've always had a healthy skepticism of "miracle" medical claims, even before COVID. And because of my background, I could immediately tell that the mRNA shots were going to be a problem, even before they were released. But that's old history; it really is time to move on from COVID.

Also because of my background, I can tell when clinical trials and medical research is legit. This is what's missing from the "armchair expert" naysayers who poo-poo every new medical discovery without proof. THOSE are the people who need to "get off my lawn!" :-)

pretty-red, old guy's avatar

Randy, is this entirely true, re Trumpie? : "HIS brilliant idea to relieve the manufacturers of all liability . . ."

What about the PREP Act and EUA?

Wasn't Trumpie simply guilty of believing the misdirection(lies) from his experts and Fauci, et al? Please illuminate the nuance here. thanks.

Randy's avatar

This is getting pretty far afield from the creatine post, but since you brought it up, I asked Brave AI: “How did it happen that Pfizer and Moderna bear no liability for harm caused by their mRNA shots for COVID?”

Pfizer and Moderna are shielded from liability primarily due to the Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act (PREP Act), a federal law invoked by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) in early 2020 [Trump’s tenure].

This declaration grants broad immunity from lawsuits to vaccine manufacturers, distributors, and healthcare providers for any claims related to the development, production, or administration of COVID-19 countermeasures.

The legal framework is designed to accelerate vaccine deployment during public health emergencies by removing the financial risk of litigation for private companies.

The Public Readiness and Emergency Preparedness Act was signed into law by George W. Bush in 2005, in the wake of the avian influenza scare. Its purpose was to give the HHS Secretary a tool to declare that, during a public health emergency, certain entities would be shielded from tort liability for their work on medical countermeasures.

On March 10, 2020 (retroactive to February 4), HHS Secretary Alex Azar invoked the PREP Act for COVID-19. The original declaration was amended at least 12 times across both the Trump and Biden administrations, each time broadening scope:

* 1st Amendment (April 2020): Added NIOSH-approved respiratory protective devices (N95 masks) as covered countermeasures.

* 2nd Amendment (July 2020): Expanded "covered persons" to include private businesses acting as program planners and clarified that activities authorized by an "authority having jurisdiction" (e.g., CDC guidance) qualify.

* 3rd Amendment (August 2020): Extended immunity to routine childhood vaccines, on the theory that the pandemic's disruption of vaccination schedules created a secondary disease threat.

* 4th Amendment (December 2020): Extended immunity to prioritization and allocation decisions (e.g., choosing who gets the last dose), and to "other diseases, health conditions, or threats that may have been caused by COVID-19."

(The original declaration and all 4 of these expansions were during Trump’s tenure.)

——-

“Okay,” you say, “so it’s not Trump’s fault; it’s George W Bush’s fault.” But not so fast… This all happened under the watchful eye of the Trump administration. George W Bush was nowhere to be found in 2020.

——-

“What role did President Trump have in the original invocation of the PREP Act in March, 2020, and its expansion throughout his term?”

Trump's role was indirect but significant — he never personally invoked the PREP Act, because the statute vests that authority in the HHS Secretary, not the President. Here's the breakdown:

The Original Invocation (March 10, 2020)

The declaration was issued by HHS Secretary Alex Azar, whom Trump had nominated and who was serving at the time. The White House's role was one of public endorsement: the day after the declaration, Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany issued a statement praising it, noting that "the Secretary of Health and Human Services has already taken bold steps to incentivize the development of vaccines, therapeutics and other products." Trump himself did not sign an executive order or memorandum invoking the PREP Act — it was a unilateral HHS action under 42 U.S.C. § 247d-6d.

The CARES Act (March 27, 2020)

This is where Trump's role became more direct. He signed the CARES Act into law, which included § 3103 — a statutory amendment to the PREP Act that added NIOSH-approved respiratory protective devices (N95 masks, etc.) to the list of covered countermeasures. This gave the HHS Secretary the legal hook to issue the First Amendment (April 15, 2020) extending immunity to PPE.

In Summary

Trump's direct, formal role was limited to signing the CARES Act (which legislatively expanded the PREP Act's scope) and appointing the Secretary who wielded the declaration power. The operational decisions — what to cover, whom to immunize, how broadly to read "covered person" and "causal relationship" — were made by Azar's office and the HHS General Counsel. The White House's function was largely one of political support and non-interference, allowing the HHS to repeatedly and aggressively broaden the declaration's scope without pushback.

——-

So it was TRUMP’S HHS Secretary who invoked the PREP Act, after TRUMP initiated the “Warp Speed” vaccine development program, due to TRUMP’S COVID Czar (Anthony Fauci) declaring that COVID was a public health emergency — a necessary step in invoking the PREP Act. Remember, the buck stops at the top.

(U.S. President Harry S. Truman famously popularized the phrase "the buck stops here," which he displayed on a sign in his Oval Office to signify that he accepted ultimate responsibility for presidential decisions and would not pass blame to others.)

Nasty1's avatar

Creatine is probably one of the the most legitimately well studied supplement out there. That being said one has to be careful as it can stress the kidneys. I use 5 gm on workout days and leave the rest alone.

Nasty1's avatar

Were BUN, creatinine and GFR measured in participants?

Dick Minnis's avatar

I take creatin daily but only 5g as that was recommended by my original source. Would 10g be to much long term, like every day all the time?

David Parnell's avatar

Any concerns with damage to kidneys?

George Skene's avatar

But can creatine harm my liver?

Marya Merritt's avatar

Thank you NIcolas! You sir, are brillant!

Leslie H MSc's avatar

Thank you for the study note, so we can look it up. Because we need close understanding of the living context.

With respect , we might sense there is more revelation needed in your reporting . What was the reference group or population’s true age range (middle age and older is a broad idea without functional markers), gender, typical hydration, standard diet, meat eaters or not, pre-study, study period and post-study macro and micro-nutrient intake, sun exposure etc?

I humbly observe that public ‘health’ product reports made without characterizing the test subject population are missing essential information required for meaningful interpretation.

Readers must wonder about the biological inferences built into conclusions about product effects. In principle and practice, material effects of a nutritional supplement cannot necessarily be generalized from test results described in terms of product effects on ‘people’ any more on the health side of the public biology equation than in the disease-driven standards. Without the human subject info, the report on the study is as useful as the messages from authorities like Dr Fauci and colleagues who claimed they took a shot their own contractors made, know they are alive months or years later m, and therefore have the science needed to promote the gross assumption that a novel mRNA vaccine and its platforms are safe and. effective for everyone.

Lone Star's avatar

How many people were in the study?

Brad Parsons's avatar

Creatine also retains water. That was probably almost all of the 2.4 lbs. Creatine combined with the wrong drugs or supplements can cause kidney damage. Know before you do.

Deep Dive's avatar

Nic, regarding this:

" Participants taking creatine without structured exercise gained about 2.4 pounds of lean tissue mass in 12 weeks "

An interesting perspective is that natural (w/o steroids) athletes in weight training to gain lean mass would have achieved an approximate 4.0-pound gain in lean mass in those 12 weeks. In other words, the yahoos who simply drank powdered creatine without exercise ended up with over half of the gain that they would have gotten by busting their A$$e$ in the gym for 3-6 hours per week!

Life isn't fair!

:-)

Tina_4Love's avatar

Thank you Nicholas this is really helpful.